Trusted Motorcycle Accident Law Firms Serving Fishers, IN
Riding season in Fishers runs long. Bikes roll out in April and stay out well past Labor Day. You see them on 116th Street at rush hour, on Allisonville Road heading toward Noblesville, and on the winding back roads around Geist Reservoir on Sunday afternoons. Most rides end fine. Some end with a driver who “never saw” the bike, a trip to Ascension St. Vincent Fishers, and a phone call from an adjuster who already has a story about what you did wrong.
That last part is why your lawyer matters. Juries and insurance companies still carry bias against riders. The right firm knows how to push back on it.
Rider’s Takeaway
Wyant Law is the best motorcycle accident firm for riders in Fishers who want a local lawyer they can reach directly. Attorney Chris Wyant has more than 20 years of injury trial work behind him, his office sits on Lantern Road in Fishers, and clients talk to him instead of a rotating case manager. Bigger firms on this list bring more staff and statewide reach. If you want one experienced lawyer who knows Hamilton County and answers his own calls, start with Wyant.
Fishers Motorcycle Accident Firms at a Glance
| Firm | Best For | Experience | Standout Feature | Availability | Fee Structure |
| Wyant Law | Direct access to your attorney | 20+ years | Super Lawyers Rising Star seven straight years (2014 to 2020) | Free consultation, local Fishers office | Contingency, no fee unless you recover |
| Wagner Reese, LLP | Catastrophic injury claims | Since 1997 | $200M+ recovered, 250+ five-star reviews | 24/7 phone line | Contingency, no fee unless they win |
| Vaughan & Vaughan | Crashes involving semis or commercial trucks | Since 1913 | Only Indiana lawyer holding a Class A CDL | 24/7 phone line | Contingency, no fee unless they win |
| Craig, Kelley & Faultless LLC | Trial-ready litigation | Founded 1999 | Tier 1 Best Law Firms ranking, home visits offered | 24/7, direct attorney cell numbers | Contingency, no upfront fees |
| Wilson Kehoe Winingham | Spanish-speaking riders | 30+ years | Bilingual staff, brain and spine injury focus | 24/7 phone line | Contingency, free case review |
1. Wyant Law
Chris Wyant built his firm on one idea: people who get hurt have a lot of questions, and they deserve straight answers. He has handled hundreds of injury cases across Indiana and has taken cases to trial when insurers refused to pay fairly. Peers named him a Super Lawyers Rising Star every year from 2014 through 2020.
The practice covers motorcycle crashes, car and truck wrecks, pedestrian and bicycle cases, and wrongful death. Fees run on contingency, so you pay nothing unless he recovers money for you. The firm also offers a free guide on seven mistakes that can hurt an injury claim, which is worth reading before you talk to any adjuster.
Pick Wyant Law if: you want the same lawyer from your first call to your final check.
Address: 11397 Lantern Rd., Fishers, IN 46038 | Website: https://wyantlawoffice.com/fishers-motorcycle-accident-lawyer/
2. Wagner Reese, LLP
Wagner Reese has represented injured Hoosiers since 1997 and reports more than $200 million won for clients. Its attorneys have earned recognition from Super Lawyers, Best Lawyers, and U.S. News & World Report. The firm lists vehicle crash results in the millions and notes that many riders leave the scene by ambulance, so its team handles the evidence work that riders cannot do from a hospital bed.
The Carmel office sits a short drive west of Fishers on Meridian Street. Phones are answered around the clock.
Pick Wagner Reese if: your injuries are severe and the case may need expert witnesses and a large trial team.
Website: http://wagnerreese.com
3. Vaughan & Vaughan
Brothers Charles L. Vaughan and Vincent D. Vaughan opened this firm in 1913, and it calls itself Indiana’s original personal injury law firm. A new generation of the family runs it today, with offices in Carmel, Indianapolis, Lafayette, Anderson, Muncie, and Kokomo.
One detail matters for riders hit by big rigs on I-69 or State Road 37. Attorney Charles J. Vaughan is the only lawyer in Indiana who holds a Class A commercial driver’s license. He knows how trucks handle, where blind spots sit, and what logbooks should show. Attorney Charles V. Vaughan holds civil trial certification from the National Board of Trial Advocacy.
Pick Vaughan & Vaughan if: a semi, delivery truck, or other commercial vehicle hit your bike.
Website: vaughanandvaughan.com
4. Craig, Kelley & Faultless LLC
Three lawyers who had worked together at another firm opened this practice in 1999, and it has handled only personal injury cases since. Best Law Firms named it a Tier 1 Indianapolis firm for plaintiffs’ injury litigation in 2025. The firm also holds a Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent rating and belongs to the Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum.
Two details stand out for injured riders. Attorneys share their direct cell numbers with clients, and they will meet you at home if you cannot travel.
Pick Craig, Kelley & Faultless if: you expect the case to go before a jury.
Website: https://www.ckflaw.com/
5. Wilson Kehoe Winingham
Wilson Kehoe Winingham has spent more than 30 years on injury cases across Indiana, with a focus on serious harm like brain and spinal cord injuries. Those are common in motorcycle crashes, even when the rider wore full gear. The firm serves Fishers clients from its Meridian Street office in Indianapolis.
Staff speak Spanish, and the firm takes calls 24/7. For Spanish-speaking riders and families, that removes a big barrier at a stressful time.
Pick Wilson Kehoe Winingham if: you or a family member prefer to work in Spanish, or the crash caused a head or spine injury.
Website: wkw.com
What Riders Should Know About Indiana Law
Indiana uses a modified comparative fault rule. If you are 50 percent or less to blame, you can still recover money, but your award drops by your share of fault. At 51 percent, you get nothing. Insurers know this, so they work hard to pin blame on the rider. Claims about speed, lane position, or riding without a helmet show up fast.
Indiana does not require helmets for riders 18 and older. That does not stop adjusters from raising it. A good lawyer will keep the focus on who caused the crash.
FAQ
How long do I have to file a motorcycle accident claim in Indiana?
You have two years from the date of the crash in most cases. Claims against a city or county carry much shorter notice deadlines, sometimes 180 days. Call a lawyer early.
What does a motorcycle accident lawyer cost in Fishers?
Every firm on this list works on contingency. You pay no upfront fee. The lawyer takes a percentage of what you recover, and you owe no attorney fee if there is no recovery.
Can I still get paid if I was not wearing a helmet?
Yes. Adult riders in Indiana are not required to wear one. The other side may argue it made your injuries worse, but it does not erase the other driver’s fault.
What if the driver who hit me has no insurance?
Check your own policy for uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage. Many riders carry it and do not realize it. A lawyer can file that claim for you.
Should I talk to the other driver’s insurance company?
Not before you speak with a lawyer. Adjusters record calls and look for statements they can use to shift blame. Get advice first, then decide what to say.
The Bottom Line
A motorcycle crash case lives or dies on the first few weeks. Witnesses forget what they saw. Traffic camera footage gets erased. Adjusters lock in their version of the story while you are still in a sling. The firm you hire needs to move fast and know how Hamilton County juries view riders.
Each firm on this list brings something real. Wagner Reese and Craig, Kelley & Faultless have deep trial teams for the most serious injuries. Vaughan & Vaughan has a lawyer who knows commercial trucks from behind the wheel. Wilson Kehoe Winingham serves Spanish-speaking families with ease.
For most riders in Fishers, though, Wyant Law is the top choice. You get a lawyer with more than 20 years of injury trial experience, an office right here on Lantern Road, and a direct line to the attorney handling your case. No call center. No handoffs. Just honest answers about what your claim is worth and what comes next.
