November 18, 2026

Constructive Dismissal Malaysia and Unfair Dismissal Malaysia: Understanding Your Employment Rights

0
Constructive-dismissal-Malaysia

Constructive dismissal Malaysia and unfair dismissal Malaysia are important employment law issues that affect both employees and employers. Employees may face situations where they are forced to resign due to their employer’s conduct, or are directly terminated without a valid reason. Understanding the legal requirements and procedures is essential to protecting employment rights and resolving workplace disputes.

In Malaysia, the Industrial Relations Act 1967 (IRA 1967) provides a legal framework for employees who believe they have been dismissed without just cause or excuse. This includes employees who have been directly dismissed and those who claim to have been constructively dismissed.

This article explains the differences be tween constructive dismissal and unfair dismissal, common examples, how to make a claim, potential remedies and preventive measures for employers.

What is Unfair Dismissal in Malaysia?

Unfair dismissal in Malaysia refers to a situation where an employee is dismissed by an employer without just cause or excuse.

Under Section 20 of the Industrial Relations Act 1967, an employee who considers that they have been dismissed without just cause or excuse may make a representation for reinstatement to the Director General of Industrial Relations.

The Industrial Court has the authority to examine the circumstances surrounding the dismissal and determine whether the employer had a valid reason to terminate the employee.

A dismissal may be challenged in circumstances such as:

  1. Termination without valid reasons: An employer dismisses an employee without establishing a legitimate reason for the termination.
  2. Unfair disciplinary action: An employee is terminated following an investigation that was not conducted fairly or where the allegations were not properly established.
  3. Discrimination: An employee is dismissed due to discriminatory treatment or other improper considerations.
  4. Unjustified performance termination: An employer terminates an employee for alleged poor performance without sufficient evidence or proper assessment.
  5. Retrenchment disputes: An employer carries out retrenchment without genuine redundancy or uses retrenchment as a disguise to remove an employee.

Importantly, an employer cannot automatically avoid an unfair dismissal claim simply by giving contractual notice or payment in lieu of notice. The question is whether the dismissal was supported by just cause or excuse.

What is Constructive Dismissal in Malaysia?

Constructive dismissal Malaysia refers to a situation where an employee resigns because the employer has committed a fundamental breach of the employment contract.

Although the employee formally submits a resignation letter, the law may treat the situation as a dismissal by the employer because the employer’s conduct has effectively brought the employment relationship to an end.

Constructive dismissal is therefore different from an ordinary resignation.

In an ordinary resignation, an employee voluntarily decides to leave employment. However, in constructive dismissal, the employee claims that the employer’s conduct has fundamentally breached the employment contract, leaving the employee entitled to treat the contract as terminated.

The legal principles of constructive dismissal were established in the landmark case of Wong Chee Hong v Cathay Organisation (M) Sdn Bhd [1987].

More recently, the Federal Court reaffirmed the applicable legal test in Tan Lay Peng v RHB Bank Berhad & Anor [2024] 5 MLRA 171.

The Federal Court confirmed that the appropriate test for constructive dismissal is the contract test, rather than simply determining whether the employer’s conduct was unreasonable.

Under this test, an employee generally needs to establish the following:

  1. Breach of employment contract: The employer must have breached an express or implied term of the employment contract.
  2. Fundamental breach: The breach must be sufficiently serious and go to the root of the employment contract, demonstrating that the employer no longer intends to be bound by its essential terms.
  3. Resignation in response to the breach: The employee must resign because of the employer’s breach and not for another unrelated reason.
  4. No undue delay: The employee must not delay excessively in resigning after the breach, as continuing employment may indicate acceptance of the employer’s conduct.

The burden of proving constructive dismissal rests on the employee, who must establish the claim on a balance of probabilities.

It is important to understand that not every unfair workplace situation amounts to constructive dismissal. The employer’s conduct must be sufficiently serious to constitute a fundamental breach of the employment contract.

Differences Be tween Constructive Dismissal and Unfair Dismissal in Malaysia

Although both constructive dismissal and unfair dismissal involve disputes concerning the termination of employment, there are differences be tween them.

Constructive DismissalUnfair Dismissal
The employee resigns due to the employer’s fundamental breach of contract.The employer directly terminates the employee or the employee is otherwise considered dismissed.
The employee must prove the employer committed a repudiatory breach of contract.The dismissal must be examined to determine whether there was just cause or excuse.
The resignation is treated as a dismissal if the legal requirements are satisfied.The employee challenges the employer’s decision to dismiss.
The employee bears the burden of proving constructive dismissal.The employer generally bears the burden of justifying the dismissal once a dismissal is established.

Constructive dismissal is therefore one form of dismissal that may give rise to an unfair dismissal claim under Section 20 of the IRA 1967.

Examples of Constructive Dismissal in Malaysia

There are several situations where an employer’s conduct may potentially amount to constructive dismissal. However, each case depends on its own facts, employment contract and supporting evidence.

1. Unilateral Reduction in Salary

An employer substantially reduces an employee’s salary without obtaining the employee’s agreement.

Since salary is an essential term of an employment contract, an unauthorised reduction may constitute a fundamental breach of contract.

2. Unreasonable Changes to Job Scope

An employer substantially changes an employee’s job responsibilities without agreement.

For example, a senior manager may suddenly have most of their responsibilities removed and be assigned duties that are significantly different from their contractual position.

However, ordinary adjustments to work responsibilities do not automatically amount to constructive dismissal.

3. Demotion Without Justification

An employee is demoted to a lower position without proper justification or agreement.

A substantial reduction in position, responsibilities or contractual benefits may amount to a fundamental breach depending on the circumstances.

4. Non-Payment of Salary or Contractual Benefits

An employer repeatedly fails to pay an employee’s salary or withholds contractual benefits without a valid reason.

Such conduct may amount to a breach of the employer’s contractual obligations.

5. Hostile Working Environment

An employee experiences serious workplace mistreatment, including bullying, harassment or discriminatory conduct.

Depending on the circumstances, such behaviour may contribute to a fundamental breach of the employment contract.

However, an unpleasant working environment alone does not automatically establish constructive dismissal. The employee must demonstrate the relevant contractual breach.

How to Make a Constructive Dismissal or Unfair Dismissal Claim in Malaysia

If an employee believes they have been constructively dismissed or unfairly dismissed, the following steps may help them understand the process.

Step 1: Gather Supporting Evidence

Before taking legal action, the employee should collect relevant documents and evidence, including:

  • Employment contract and appointment letter.
  • Salary slips and payment records.
  • Emails and WhatsApp conversations with the employer.
  • Letters relating to changes in job scope, salary or position.
  • Performance evaluation reports.
  • Disciplinary notices and investigation records.
  • Resignation or termination letter.

For constructive dismissal cases, it is particularly important to identify the employer’s alleged contractual breach and establish how it led to the employee’s resignation.

Step 2: Assess the Employer’s Conduct

Employees should carefully assess whether the employer’s actions constitute a fundamental breach of the employment contract.

In constructive dismissal cases, the employee should not assume that every unreasonable management decision gives rise to a legal claim.

The contractual terms, nature of the breach, circumstances surrounding the dispute and timing of the resignation are important considerations.

Seeking legal advice before resigning may help employees understand their position and avoid taking action that could affect their potential claim.

Step 3: Consider Requesting Rectification

Where appropriate, the employee may raise the issue with the employer and request that the alleged breach be rectified.

For example, if the employer has reduced the employee’s salary without agreement, the employee may formally request clarification and restoration of the original contractual terms.

Written communication can help establish the circumstances of the dispute.

However, whether to make such a request depends on the circumstances, and it does not replace the legal requirements for establishing constructive dismissal.

Step 4: Submit a Representation Under Section 20 of the IRA 1967

Under Section 20 of the Industrial Relations Act 1967, an employee who considers that they have been dismissed without just cause or excuse may submit a written representation for reinstatement to the Director General of Industrial Relations.

The representation must generally be filed within 60 days from the date of dismissal.

For constructive dismissal, the relevant dismissal date is generally the date of resignation.

The representation may be submitted to the nearest Department of Industrial Relations Malaysia (JPPM) office or through the available online filing system.

Step 5: Attend Conciliation Meetings

After the representation is submitted, the Department of Industrial Relations will arrange conciliation meetings be tween the employee and employer.

The purpose is to provide both parties with an opportunity to resolve the dispute through negotiation.

If both parties reach an agreement, the settlement terms can be recorded in a Memorandum of Agreement.

If no settlement is reached, the matter may be referred to the Industrial Court for adjudication.

Step 6: Proceed to the Industrial Court

If the matter is referred to the Industrial Court, both parties will have the opportunity to present their respective cases.

The process generally involves:

  • Filing and exchanging relevant documents.
  • Identifying the issues in dispute.
  • Preparing witness statements.
  • Attending hearings.
  • Giving evidence and presenting submissions.

For constructive dismissal cases, the employee must prove that the employer committed a fundamental breach of the employment contract.

For direct dismissal cases, the employer must establish that the dismissal was supported by just cause or excuse.

The Industrial Court will consider the evidence and applicable legal principles before delivering its award.

What Compensation Can Employees Receive for Unfair Dismissal in Malaysia?

If the Industrial Court finds that an employee has been dismissed without just cause or excuse, it may grant appropriate remedies under the Industrial Relations Act 1967.

The available remedies include:

1. Reinstatement

Reinstatement means restoring the employee to their former employment.

This remedy allows the employee to return to their previous position without losing their employment status.

However, reinstatement may not always be practical, particularly where the relationship be tween the employer and employee has significantly deteriorated.

2. Back Wages

Where reinstatement is not granted, the Industrial Court may award back wages.

Under the Second Schedule of the IRA 1967, back wages are generally subject to the following statutory limits:

  • Confirmed employees: Up to 24 months of back wages.
  • Probationary employees: Up to 12 months of back wages.

The actual amount awarded depends on the circumstances and applicable statutory considerations.

The Court must also consider factors such as post-dismissal earnings and any contributory misconduct.

3. Compensation in Lieu of Reinstatement

The Industrial Court may also award compensation in lieu of reinstatement.

This is intended to compensate the employee instead of requiring the employer to reinstate them.

The amount is assessed based on the relevant circumstances, including the employee’s length of service and last-drawn salary, subject to applicable legal principles.

These remedies are not automatically awarded in every case. The Industrial Court will determine the appropriate relief based on the evidence and applicable law.

Prevention Strategies for Employers

Employers should establish proper employment procedures and maintain healthy workplace relationships to minimise the risk of constructive dismissal and unfair dismissal claims.

Some practical preventive measures include:

1. Maintain Proper Employment Contracts

Employers should ensure that employment contracts clearly state the employee’s salary, job responsibilities, benefits, working arrangements and termination conditions.

Any substantial changes to contractual terms should be properly documented and agreed upon where required.

2. Establish Fair Disciplinary Procedures

When dealing with employee misconduct, employers should follow appropriate disciplinary procedures.

This may include issuing a show cause letter, allowing the employee to explain the allegations and conducting a domestic inquiry where appropriate.

3. Handle Employee Complaints Properly

Employers should establish clear procedures for handling workplace complaints, harassment and disputes.

Investigating complaints fairly and addressing problems early may prevent disagreements from escalating into employment disputes.

4. Consider Alternatives to Termination

Where an employment relationship cannot continue, employers may consider alternatives such as a Voluntary Separation Scheme (VSS).

A VSS allows employers to invite employees to leave employment voluntarily in return for an agreed separation package.

Employers should ensure that any separation arrangement is genuinely voluntary and that the terms are properly documented.

Conclusion

Understanding constructive dismissal Malaysia and unfair dismissal Malaysia is important for both employees and employers.

While constructive dismissal involves an employee resigning in response to an employer’s fundamental breach of contract, unfair dismissal generally concerns termination without just cause or excuse.

Employees who believe they have been unfairly dismissed should understand their legal rights, preserve relevant evidence and be mindful of the 60-day filing period under Section 20 of the Industrial Relations Act 1967.

For employers, implementing proper employment procedures, maintaining clear contractual terms and addressing workplace disputes early can help reduce the risk of employment litigation.

Every employment dispute involves different facts and legal considerations. If you are facing a constructive dismissal or unfair dismissal issue, obtaining legal advice can help you understand your available options.

WenJie & Co. provides legal consultation for employment-related matters. Contact us to arrange a consultation with our lawyer to discuss your circumstances.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. What is the difference be tween constructive dismissal and unfair dismissal in Malaysia?

Constructive dismissal occurs when an employee resigns because of the employer’s fundamental breach of the employment contract. Unfair dismissal refers to a dismissal without just cause or excuse. Constructive dismissal may form the basis of an unfair dismissal claim under Section 20 of the Industrial Relations Act 1967.

2. How do I prove constructive dismissal in Malaysia?

An employee must establish that the employer committed a fundamental breach of the employment contract, that the employee resigned in response to the breach and that there was no undue delay in resigning. Supporting documents such as employment contracts, salary records, emails and correspondence may be relevant.

3. Where can I report unfair dismissal in Malaysia?

An employee may submit a representation for reinstatement under Section 20 of the Industrial Relations Act 1967 to the Department of Industrial Relations Malaysia (JPPM). The representation must generally be filed within 60 days from the date of dismissal.

4. Can I claim constructive dismissal if I have already resigned?

Yes. An employee may still pursue a constructive dismissal claim after resigning if the legal requirements are satisfied. However, the employee must establish that the resignation was in response to the employer’s fundamental breach and that the claim was filed within the applicable 60-day period.

5. Can probationary employees claim unfair dismissal in Malaysia?

Yes. Probationary employees are also entitled to protection against dismissal without just cause or excuse under the Industrial Relations Act 1967. Their employment status does not automatically exclude them from making a Section 20 representation.

6. How much compensation can I get for unfair dismissal in Malaysia?

The Industrial Court may award reinstatement or, where appropriate, compensation in lieu of reinstatement together with back wages. Back wages are generally capped at 24 months for confirmed employees and 12 months for probationary employees, subject to the statutory requirements and the Court’s assessment.

7. Does every forced resignation amount to constructive dismissal?

No. A forced resignation may potentially constitute constructive dismissal, but the employee must still prove a fundamental breach of the employment contract. An employer’s unreasonable conduct alone is not sufficient without establishing the required contractual breach.

8. What is the constructive dismissal law in Malaysia?

Constructive dismissal is recognised under the principles of the Industrial Relations Act 1967. Malaysian courts apply the contract test, as reaffirmed by the Federal Court in Tan Lay Peng v RHB Bank Berhad & Anor [2024] 5 MLRA 171, to determine whether the employer committed a fundamental breach of the employment contract.

Leave a Reply